Skip to main content

[jsr363-experts] Specification not ready for a release today

  • From: Martin Desruisseaux < >
  • To:
  • Subject: [jsr363-experts] Specification not ready for a release today
  • Date: Wed, 17 Dec 2014 18:34:29 +0900
  • Organization: Geomatys

I have spent the last days on the specification, but I think that there
is still a long way to go. This specification seems to have never been
seriously reviewed. It contains copy-and-paste from JSR-275 applied in
great confusion (copying implementation-specific details in the API
chapter, copying general concepts in the "Implementation" chapter),
texts that have not been re-read (API that do not exist anymore, wrong
type hierarchy, goals & aspirations in contradiction with current
implementation), often no formatting (bullet lists without bullets), etc.

I had a look at the "early draft" of other JSR. Even if they are "early
draft", their documents seem clean and well organized. Our specification
is not at this stage. I'm still working on it, but given the amount of
work needed, I have not yet finished.

Given the above, I would really like for more delay. This specification
is not ready in my opinion, even for an early draft. I know that there
is a desire for meeting some F2F calendar, but I don't think that it can
be done at the expense of loosing reviewer's time with a document hard
to read or inaccurate regarding the actual JSR-363 design.

    Martin



[jsr363-experts] Specification not ready for a release today

Martin Desruisseaux 12/17/2014

[jsr363-experts] Re: Specification not ready for a release today

Werner Keil 12/17/2014

[jsr363-experts] Re: Specification not ready for a release today

Martin Desruisseaux 12/17/2014

[jsr363-experts] Re: Specification not ready for a release today

Werner Keil 12/17/2014

[jsr363-experts] Re: Specification not ready for a release today

Martin Desruisseaux 12/17/2014

[jsr363-experts] Re: Specification not ready for a release today

Werner Keil 12/17/2014

[jsr363-experts] Re: Specification not ready for a release today

Martin Desruisseaux 12/17/2014

[jsr363-experts] Re: Specification not ready for a release today

Leonardo Lima 12/17/2014

[jsr363-experts] Re: Specification not ready for a release today

Werner Keil 12/17/2014

[jsr363-experts] Re: Specification not ready for a release today

Martin Desruisseaux 12/18/2014

[jsr363-experts] Re: Specification not ready for a release today

Werner Keil 12/18/2014
 
 
Close
loading
Please Confirm
Close